| Has
the Internet helped to bring generations of Sikhs closer together
through a better understanding of their common faith or is it instead
helping to widen the generation gap? Although on the surface one could
assume that a better understanding of the religion would lead to a
closing of the gap between the current generation of Sikhs and their
parents, a closer look at the Internet as a mechanism of knowledge
transfer would seem to suggest otherwise.
While older generations have traditionally been used to reading
the Sikh scriptures and books about Sikhism in Gurmukhi and Punjabi,
newer generations are more comfortable with English. The Internet
remains mainly an English medium. Even though other non-English
languages have made some inroads in this regard, the technology
does not easily facilitate the use of Gurmukhi characters. There
are no web browser or email standards for the transmission and viewing
of Gurmukhi characters. This has for the most part meant that the
majority of information on the Internet and the email discussions
being carried out are being done so in English. Sri Guru Granth
Sahib is available in Gurmukhi on the Internet but little else in
the way of material about the religion in Gurmukhi script has made
it online. By contrast there are plenty of books on Sikhism in English
on the Internet.
Whereas older generations have traditionally defined a 'good Sikh'
as one who follows the traditions and rituals with unquestioning
faith, for younger generations this is not enough. They are not
willing to follow the traditional devotional approach with its emphasis
on rituals and less on philosophy. The Internet is being used by
Sikhs to dig deeper into their religion. The new generations of
Diaspora Sikhs if they express any interest in the religion are
interested more in knowing 'why'. They are not willing to accept
Sikhism based on the 'no questions' traditional approach, which
has been passed down for generations. They are more sophisticated
than previous generations have ever been in this regard or were
ever allowed to be and want to know about the mechanisms of the
religion, how it's philosophy compares with other faiths, how relevant
the religion is today and where the religion stands on contemporary
social issues.
The newer generation of Sikhs has evolved a more analytic approach
that differs considerably from the devotional approach of previous
generations. As most of the material on the Internet has been written
by their own contemporaries it also follows this quantifiable and
analytic approach in it's presentation and content. One can do key-word
searches of the Guru Granth Sahib online, look at the writings classified
by author and look at various aspects of Sikh theology by subject
matter. This analytic approach previously only the domain of scholars
is eagerly being adopted by the newer generations as they surf the
net and email each other. It is a true peer-to-peer use of the technology,
where they are more interested in learning about their religion
online, looking at content developed by their own peers in different
parts of the world. They are learning more about the religion than
what they have ever learned traditionally from their families or
at the Gurdwara. Topics which would be considered 'taboo' such as
homosexuality, sex and gender equality are being discussedy
on the Internet as Sikhs seek to understand their religion and where
it and they fit in into the bigger picture of life and society.
After reading and having online discussion about highly 'technical'
aspects of the religion on the Internet when they start asking their
parents questions, in many cases they are not getting answers that
make sense to them. Their parents and the older generations were
raised in that traditional devotional approach in which emphasis
was placed on the proper etiquette, prayers and rituals of the religion
and less on understanding the underlying philosophical mechanisms.
This has been the approach for hundreds of years, but it does not
seem to be one that makes the most sense to the younger Sikhs of
the Internet age. They seek to understand first and then develop
a sense of respect, love and devotion, rather than the other way
around.
The oral tradition, used for hundreds of years to pass on stories
and parables about the religion is slowly being lost. The new generation
is not as interested in hearing stories from their elders or at
the Gurdwara, of Guru Nanak performing miracles such as stopping
a boulder with his bare hands. There is not that same sense of wonderment
that older generations have when hearing such stories. They feel
that 'miracles' are not enough of a justification or validation
of the religion and need more. The younger generations are much
more sophisticated and would rather spend their time on the Internet
taking a more hard and analytic approach to finding information
and learning than the 'soft', and what they consider simplistic,
approach of the traditional oral tradition. Whereas Baba Nanak causing
Mecca to move when his feet were moved by the Qazi seems to hold
a greater sense of wonderment and validation of the greatness of
Sikhism and the power of the Gurus for the older generations, the
younger generations are more likely to go to the Internet and look
at a comparative analysis of the similarities and differences between
Sikhism and Islam or do a keyword search of the Guru Granth Sahib
to read contextual references to Mecca.
Sandeep Singh (Brar) is an Internet technologist and developer
of the widely acclaimed website www.sikhs.org.
|